Bottom sheet ui for google auth on android

[yakovyarmo]

How can we show the new ui for goole auth on android?

[WcaleNieWolny]

Bottom sheet ui

You cannot. I assume that this is the UI that you are talking about:

You CANNOT show show this "new UI" with this plugin. This is a deliberate choice and not a design oversight.
This "new UI" is closer to Google's One Tap API. Currently, one tap is not supported on any platform.

[yakovyarmo]

Regarding the new UI implementation request:

I understand this was a deliberate design choice, but I believe there's value in reconsidering:

Benefits

• 🚀 Better UX: Matches modern auth patterns users expect
• 🛠️ Developer Flexibility: Optional feature for those who need it
• 🔄 Industry Alignment: Keeps plugin competitive with alternatives

Suggestion

Could we consider adding this as an optional UI variant? This would:

• Maintain backward compatibility
• Give developers choice
• Not interfere with core functionality

I'm willing to help with implementation/documentation if you're open to discussing this approach.

What are your thoughts on exploring this as a configurable option?

[WcaleNieWolny]

I am more than happy to welcome a PR, but only if this "one tap" api works across all platforms (iOS, web, Android)

I know that it's possible to do one tap on the web and on Android, but I am not sure about iOS

[yakovyarmo]

I appreciate your openness to the PR, but I should mention that iOS's security model may make a true 'one tap' API impossible on that platform. Would you still be interested in implementing this for Android/web users, with a fallback flow for iOS? That way we could improve the experience for the majority of users while maintaining functionality for iOS

…

On Sun, 3 Nov 2024, 20:49 WcaleNieWolny, ***@***.***> wrote: I am more than happy to welcome a PR, but only if this "one tap" api works across all platforms (iOS, web, Android) I know that it's possible to do one tap on the web and on Android, but I am not sure about iOS — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#45 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABGYWBOL3A2EPULAVKBCVALZ6ZV2NAVCNFSM6AAAAABRADDMD6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDINJTGUZTQNJWGM> . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[riderx]

Can you link the doc of this new modal?
We currently implement on Android the last recomended sdk

[yakovyarmo]

Can you link the doc of this new modal? We currently implement on Android the last recomended sdk

Doc for what? for the one tap?

https://developer.android.com/identity/sign-in/credential-manager-siwg

To trigger Google One Tap flow, use GetGoogleIdOption instead of GetSignInWithGoogleOption

[riderx]

@yakovyarmo have you tried the plugin?
That for me what we use

[riderx]

ok no you where right, i added newUI in option of login put it to true to test the new UI

[WcaleNieWolny]

@riderx one of my first commits back when this plugin was in its infancy was nuking one-tap from Android. Unfortunately,
one-tap poses many challenges that made in undesirable to use it as the main method of loging in.

By far the biggest issue that I faced back then was the requirement of using the device's system accounts. If the user is not logged in, this one-tap API will not allow him or her to add a new Google account.

It was also inconsistent with iOS and the web.

I am of the firm belief that providing an option for this new UI is in the best interests of the users as long as it is not default option

[riderx]

with an option i agree it good.
i realized my integration was broken, if you can have a look and add it back behind newUI flag it would be best

[yakovyarmo]

Can I offer just to add an option to the google login?

const res = await SocialLogin.login({
  provider: 'google',
  options: {
    scopes: ['email', 'profile'],
    style: 'oneTap'
  },
});

or just a new provider?

const res = await SocialLogin.login({
  provider: 'google-oneTap',
  options: {
    scopes: ['email', 'profile']
  },
});

[WcaleNieWolny]

@riderx I just remembered why I nuked the one-tap API. It's incredibly annoying to use, and frankly I struggle to get it to work

[WcaleNieWolny]

This darn API is nothing but pain. It's almost impossible to get past the androidx.credentials.exceptions.NoCredentialException: No credentials available error

[riderx]

You don’t need to handle every caee if there is a demo showing the base the comunity can improve it

[yakovyarmo]

May be you want me to help with it?
Do you have something I can test?

[WcaleNieWolny]

Sure, here are the changes: #75

[yakovyarmo]

It worked on my android device (if I remove the comments)

[yakovyarmo]

I made some changes to the file,
How can I push it for your review ?

[riderx]

yes please

[yakovyarmo]

But I have no permission to push

[riderx]

fork and do a PR

[yakovyarmo]

Just did.
Whats's next?

[WcaleNieWolny]

You wait. Merging anything into main is blocked for the next couple of days because I am porting development into main

[yakovyarmo]

Hi, what is the status for the merge?
Can I help in any way?