Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Option to sync playlists and subscriptions in their respective pages [YouTube] #2018

Closed
that404nerd opened this issue Mar 4, 2025 · 4 comments
Labels
Enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@that404nerd
Copy link

Use Cases

As the title mentions it would be great to add an option to sync all playlists and subscriptions from YouTube (if one subscribed to someone's channel or more in YouTube but not in grayjay) in their respective pages. Because currently it's located in the sources page and it's kind of a chore to open the sources page everytime. Instead it would be easy to do that if they are in the subscriptions and playlist pages. Thanks and have a nice day!

Proposal

No response

References

No response

@that404nerd that404nerd added the Enhancement New feature or request label Mar 4, 2025
@serossi
Copy link

serossi commented Mar 4, 2025

uhm what ?

this doesnt make any sense. syncing subscriptions from a creator page doesnt make any sense and there is no youtube page.
the page you see is a sources aggregator. the closest we have to a youtube page is the sources plugin and this is why this option is there.

same thing for playlists you personally created. there is no good place other than the youtube plugin because thats basically the main page for that particular source. creator playlists can be synced now in the creator tab (finally took long enough lol)

the thing you see as like main, trending etc are all aggregated across all sources. grayjay doesnt care which is the feed source.

also the idea is anyway to make you independet of the websites, once grayjay desktop works fully as intended there wont be any need for 99.99% of the users to even go on the website. manual syncing of personal playlists is already a rather fringe function, most people use that once, some sporadic.

it was more important when channel playlists didnt work, but they do now.

so i would vote to close this because its already implemented best as logically sensible in the current app structure

@serossi
Copy link

serossi commented Mar 4, 2025

let me add, i would vote for a massive overhaul of the UI and all the menues.

currently specially sources and settings menue are not that greatly structured.
things like sync stuff or manual update check etc should be on top of each respective menue for quick access among endless other things but that is another topic

@that404nerd
Copy link
Author

uhm what ?

this doesnt make any sense. syncing subscriptions from a creator page doesnt make any sense and there is no youtube page.
the page you see is a sources aggregator. the closest we have to a youtube page is the sources plugin and this is why this option is there.

same thing for playlists you personally created. there is no good place other than the youtube plugin because thats basically the main page for that particular source. creator playlists can be synced now in the creator tab (finally took long enough lol)

the thing you see as like main, trending etc are all aggregated across all sources. grayjay doesnt care which is the feed source.

also the idea is anyway to make you independet of the websites, once grayjay desktop works fully as intended there wont be any need for 99.99% of the users to even go on the website. manual syncing of personal playlists is already a rather fringe function, most people use that once, some sporadic.

it was more important when channel playlists didnt work, but they do now.

so i would vote to close this because its already implemented best as logically sensible in the current app structure

Well didn't think about the other ones. I guess you are right.

@that404nerd that404nerd closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale Mar 4, 2025
@that404nerd
Copy link
Author

let me add, i would vote for a massive overhaul of the UI and all the menues.

currently specially sources and settings menue are not that greatly structured.
things like sync stuff or manual update check etc should be on top of each respective menue for quick access among endless other things but that is another topic

You can definitely open this as another issue. Would definitely help

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants