article10.tsv

Sequence	estate	Name	Politics	Procedural	With	Valence (1= positive, 0 = neutral, -1 = negative)	Comments
1	nobility	Sixth Bureau 	traditional	C1			articles 16-18
2	clergy	Bonnal	traditional	C2	Sixth Bureau 	1	articles 16-17
3	clergy	Laborde	liberal	A5	Sixth Bureau 	-1	pro-toleration
4	third estate	Mirabeau (comte)	libertarian	A5	Sixth Bureau 	-1	toleration too weak; absolute right!
5	clergy	Eymar	conservative	C3	Sixth Bureau 	1	pro-established religion (on Anglican model)
6	third estate	Camus	conservative	C2	Eymar	1
7	third estate	Petion de Villeneuve	libertarian	A2	Sixth Bureau 	-1	rejecting arts 16-17
8	third estate	Maillot	conservative+liberal	B3	Castellane	1
9	nobility	Castellane	conservative+liberal	C1, A1			first half conservative ("La religion étant le plus solide de tous les biens politiques"), second half liberal/libertarian ("nul homme ne peut être inquiété dans ses opinions religieuses")
10	third estate	Bouche	liberal	A2	Sixth Bureau 	-1	rejecting arts 16-17
11	third estate	Bouche	conservative + libertarian	C1			refs 1785 royal decree tolerating Protestantism
12	clegy	Eymar	conservative	C2	Sixth Bureau 	1	We'll leave discussion of 'culte' until the constitution. Focus on 'religion' for good order of society.
13	third estate	Mirabeau (comte)	liberal	A5	Eymar	-1	procedural point, opposing Eymar because the motion is to postpone debate over arts. 16-17
14	nobility	Mirabeau (vicomte)	liberal	A3	Castellane	1	only "first part" ("Nul homme ne doit être inquiété pour ses opinions religieuses"); rejected second part, "ni troublé dans l'exercice de son culte"
15	nobility	Castellane		C1, A1
16	nobility	Clermont-Lodève	conservative	C3	Sixth Bureau	1	in favor of arts 16-17; cites Rousseau!
17	clergy	Talleyrand 	liberal	A5			17 belongs in the constitution and 16 is problematic.
18	nobility	Castellane	liberal	C1, A1			Renews his motion: ""Nul homme ne doit être inquiété pour ses opinions religieuses ni troublé dans l'exercice de son culte"
19	third estate	Mirabeau (comte)	libertarian	A5	Castellane	-1	attacks the second part of Castellane's motion (on the free exercise of religious culte)
20	nobility	Castellane	conservative+liberal	C4			defends his whole proposal
21	clergy	Juigné	conservative	C5	Castellane	1	Opposes the motion to remove the second part.
22	third estate	Rabaud de Saint-Etienne	liberal	C1			Rabaud speaks at length and offers a proposal in favor of religious freedom. Essentially a plea for non catholics, i.e. protestants. "Tout homme est libre dans ses opinions; tout citoyen a le droit de professer librement son culte, et nul ne peut être inquiété à cause de sa religion."
23	clergy	Gobel	conservative+liberal	A5	Rabaud de Saint-Etienne	-1	no institutionalized status of religion/just about ordre public. No one can prevent non-catholics from practicing their religion. They must do so in a way that does not disturb public order. "...pourvu que leur manifestation ne troublé pas l'ordre public."
24	unknown	anonymous	liberal	A2			"as established by the law" is added to Gobel's ammendment.
25		adopted	liberal	A1